Star Anise Ice Cream

Shoot me a jibe about my childlike obsession with ice cream and I’ll knock it back from fifty paces. It’s not dull, it’s not just for kids and I don’t need to order the gold-leaf-plated mille fuille of  fruits of Eden with a Perrier Jouet Belle Epoque sabayon; I  just want a bowl of ice cream. Its combination of baby food smoothness and melting sugared cream may be part of the appeal, yes (and classics such as raspberry ripple get me every time) but often it’s the way it so gracefully carries those grown-up flavours which has me reaching for the sundae spoon. I do love a bit of spice in my sweet stuff.

I originally envisaged this ice cream oozing all over a rhubarb galette but the recipe I used was not at all to my taste. To be fair alarm bells did ring as I was making it – 1 whole teaspoon of vanilla extract + 170g sugar must surely = sickly perfume?

The answer is yes, yes it does. The pastry was nice; I picked it off and used it as a scooper for the ice cream.

Back at my drawing board, I got a bee in the bonnet for poached pears. Simmered with a syrup laced with cloves, vanilla (half a pod) and  cinnamon stick, they were delicate, elegant and actually rather perfect. One thing missing though: pastry. Makes you wonder why I didn’t just make the pear tatins as suggested in the ice cream recipe, doesn’t it? Hmm.

Anyway, the bottom line is that the ice cream is awesome. The scary amount of star anise actually infuse just the right amount of flavour* and the base seemed particularly creamy. Now I’ve got the bug for spice I’m set on making a chocolate and cardamom version but there’s one lesson I’m taking with me and it’s this:  sometimes, a girl just needs a simple bowl of ice cream.

Star Anise Ice Cream Recipe from The Times

*I was very nervous when I clocked the amount of star anise in the recipe, but realised this is because the milk is infusing for only a short time – you need to get that flavour in fast. The end result is not overpowering.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

13 thoughts on “Star Anise Ice Cream

  1. what an unsual flavor to add to ice cream, love the first picture. rhubarb galette looks lovely, you could have told us all it was magnificent and we all would have believed you :-)

  2. That’s me sorted for my dinner party tomorrow night … I adore star anise.

    It’s very good to put some in a pan when you’re frying beef … Heston swears by it to start off a bolgnese!

  3. Anh – yes it is unusual but it really works. I was really impressed with the recipe and the spice level is spot on.

    LexEat – Ooh, now that sounds a bit good!

    Nina – That is exactly what i was dreaming of – a warm pie with a cold melting blob of ice cream on top. Dribble.

    Maninas – Thanks! Yes they do. Someone commented they also look like flies!

    Lizzie – Thanks. it certainly did look the part, which made it even more disappointing. Just a little a little tweaking though and the recipe could be a winner. The pastry was great so I’ll deifnitely use that again.

    BSG – Blimey! Avocado ice cream really does sound different. I would definitely give it a go though – never say never and all that.

    Shayma – Yeah it certainly does. SO comforting. I am a true addict.

    Caroline – I love all these comments on the anise in the cream! We’ve had flies, butterflies and now dragon flies.

    Jonathan – Yes it certainly does have that killer combination of looks and personality.

    Danny – Oh I certainly have. I much prefer ice cream mush though – which is a half melted version, mushed up into a paste and then shaped into peaks and eaten one by one. not joking.

  4. Totally agree with your sentiments about ice cream but have you ever made ice cream soup, you know where you leave it to melt a bit in the bowl and then stir. Or am I alone in this?

    Love the sound of this recipe.

  5. aw, that is a shame. i really did enjoy looking at your photos very much, as always. i agree, ice cream is like baby food, that nursery food quality. x shayma

  6. Yum – am definitely going to try this. A friend once made avocado ice-cream and it was surprisingly good – the creative juices are well and truly flowing now, thanks!

  7. Shame it wasn’t to your taste, but the galette looks AMAZING, as do the pears. I am now even more excited about experimenting with my new ice cream maker.

  8. I am sorry the gallette was not to your sure looks awesome, as for the ice-cream….I have made this before and had the same fears as you, but in the end I loved the cold/heat contrasts in my mouth….

  9. Having just polished off the coconut milk & lemongrass sorbet I made, I agree with you completely! Ice cream is not just for kids!

    This looks DIVINE and the photos beautiful!


  • 17 November 2015

    Making Hortopita with Fresh Filo in Rovies, Greece

  • 18 October 2015

    The Wye Valley: Mucking About In Hedgerows

  • 15 September 2015

    On Fear, Flying and Inflight Food

  • 02 September 2015

    The Super Maltini

  • 12 August 2015

    Panzanella Meets Caesar

  • 03 August 2015

    Iced Tea-Brined Fried Chicken with Jalapeño Slaw

  • View All